In the Name of the King: Two Worlds (2011)

In the Name of the King: Two Worlds (2011) poster
Rating:
Epic Fantasy Adventure

Uwe Boll strikes again! Sequel to his passable earlier epic fantasy, which is dragged down by a lack of action and the need to provide star Dolph Lundgren with a series of excrutiating witticims

Quarantine 2: Terminal (2011)

Rating: ★★
Zombies Overtake an Airport Terminal

A sequel to Quarantine, the English-language remake of [Rec]. Abandoning the Found Footage concept, and indeed much continuity, to the other films, this is nothing more than a standard zombie film set inside an airport terminal

Mimesis (2011)

Mimesis (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Characters Trapped in a Simulation of Night of the Living Dead

This comes with an interestingly different premise wherein characters are abducted and wake up inside a simulation of Night of the Living Dead and realise they are meant to replay the roles of the people in the farmhouse at siege from the zombie onslaught

Johnny English Reborn (2011)

Johnny English Reborn (2011) poster
Rating: ★½
Incompetent Spy Comedy

Rowan Atkinson is a very funny man but try as I might I cannot get into these Johnny English films – they seem at best lame Austin Powers castoffs with gags designed for the single digit age range

Cross (2011)

Cross (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Action Film/Mystical Artifacts

A copy of The Expendables (albeit with the addition of fantasy elements) that brings together a line-up of B-action movie actors as a team. While some of the actors shine, the feel is of a cheaper effort earnestly trying to copy its betters

Final Destination 5 (2011)

Final Destination 5 (2011) poster
Rating: ★★½
Precognition/Doomed Bridge Collapse Survivors

The series drags another entry out set around the premonition of a bridge collapse. This one is played with such an enthusiasm for the bizarrely improbable deaths that it is one of the best of the sequels

Atlas Shrugged (2011)

Atlas Shrugged (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Libertarian Political Fantasy/Ayn Rand Adaptation

The first in a three part film adaptation of Ayn Rand’s novel that makes a heavy-handed and frequently tub-thumping argument for the virtues of selfishness and despisal of any rules of fairness

Scre4m (2011)

Scre4m (2011) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Slasher Sequel Parody/Deconstruction

Wes Craven and Kevin Williamson return to the Scream franchise to turn out the fourth and best sequel yet. The opening scene alone is the funniest one has seen in a film in some time

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 (2011)

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 (2011) poster
Rating: ★★★
Young Wizard

I’ve never been a huge fan of the Harry Potter series but the final chapter rounds out the boy wizard saga in rousing style, mounting an epic-sized battle and finding characters depths that hold some of the best writing of the series

X: First Class (2011)

X: First Class (2011) poster
Rating: ★★★
Comic-Book Superheroes/Origin Prequel

An X-Men origin story that serves as the occasion to recast the series with younger actors. This works far better than the previous two films, integrating the characters in a strong story, although is quiet at the superheroic action

Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked (2011)

Alvin and the Chipmunks: Chipwrecked (2011) poster
Rating: ½
Singing Chipmunks

It may say how doomed the Western world is that people have paid to watch three films so far all centred around these annoyingly cutsie helium-voiced chipmunks. This is marginally less annoying that the preceding two

Sex and Zen: Extreme Ecstasy (2011)

Sex and Zen: Extreme Ecstasy (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Hong Kong Erotic Comedy

A revival of the 1990s Sex and Zen series of erotic comedies, this comes with the novelty of being presented in 3D

Hellraiser: Revelations (2011)

Hellraiser: Revelations (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Sadomasochistic Demons

The ninth of the films, made cheaply to extend copyright on the series and publicly pilloried by Clive Barker. For all that, it is one sequel that gets Barker’s original theme about the quest for forbidden pleasures right

Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011)

Kung Fu Panda 2 (2011) poster
Rating: ★★½
Animation/Talking Animal Martial Arts

Sequel to DreamWorks hit animated film, this does little more than repeat its predecessor. The detail and texture is amplified to a work of art, although you cannot help but wonder if the under tens care about this

The Witches of Oz (2011)

The Witches of Oz (2011) poster
Rating:
Wizard of Oz Sequel/Modernisation

Sequel/modernisation (it is confusing what) to The Wizard of Oz relocated in New York. This tv mini-series may be the cheapest work ever served up bearing the Oz name and flounders amid the shabbiness of its effects and utter lack of magic its director conjures

Grave Encounters (2011)

Grave Encounters (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Found Footage/Haunted Asylum

Another Found Footage horror film with a reality tv ghostbusting team investigating a haunted asylum. The Found Footage genre quickly became exhausted and this only treads where others have gone before

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011)

Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Pirate Fantasy Swashbuckler

The Pirates of the Caribbean franchise is revived for a fifth outing. There is a new director in Rob Marshall but bar an energetic comic opening, he never does much that hits the zany heights of the previous entries

Fright Night (2011)

Fright Night (2011) poster
Rating: ★★
Vampire Next Door Neighbour

Another 1980s horror remake that resurrects and changes the original to little purpose. This fails to understand that what was original in 1985 lacks much alongside other contemporary vampire films

Rio (2011)

Rio (2011) poster
Rating: ★★½
Animation/Talking Macaws

A Blue Sky Studios animated film set around a talking macaw and his journey to the wilds of Brazil for the first time to mate and repopulate the species. Familiar cliched story arcs conducted with a good deal of colour

Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011)

Rise of the Planet of the Apes (2011) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Planet of the Apes Prequel

Reboot of the classic franchise, a loose remake of Conquest of the Planet of the Apes. Thanks to some remarkable CGI effects, the apes entirely outshine the humans

Spy Kids: All the Time in the World (2011)

Spy Kids: All the Time in the World (2011) poster
Rating:
Juvenile Spy Adventures

A series that reached its maximum level of cuteness two films ago is dragged out for another pointless entry that nobody was asking for. Robert Rodriguez delivers shabby juvenile slapstick

The Human Centipede II (Full Sequence) (2011)

The Human Centipede II (Full Sequence) (2011) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Madman Surgically Connects Human Bodies

Sequel to the original that pushes into even more perverse territory. This throws some amusing spins on the original, creating a unique protagonist, while also contriving to exist inside an extremely disturbed headspace

Sadako 3D (2012)

Sadako 3D (2012) poster
Rating:
Ring Sequel/Japanese Ghost Story

The original Ring was a classic, an eerie ghost story that was a success that spawned a series of copies right around the Asian region. Here the Ring cycle has been rebooted in a heavy letdown that abandons all of the creepy atmospherics of the original for a series of pop-up CGI effects

Ted (2012)

Ted (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Foul-Mouthed Teddy Bear

Comedy about a foul-mouthed talking teddy bear. This gets its laughs from much scatological, decidedly non-PC humour that occasionally manages to be funny, especially when it comes to some of the 80s pop culture jokes

Ice Age: Continental Drift (2012)

Ice Age: Continental Drift (2012) poster
Rating:
Animation/Prehistoric Talking Animals

This is not a film, it is a money-making machine in the guise of a film aimed squarely at undiscerning family audiences that plays to familiar characters and comic routines and has minimal difference to the preceding three Ice Age films

The Man with the Iron Fists (2012)

The Man with the Iron Fists (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Martial Arts/Shaw Brothers Homage

RZA of rap group Wu-Tang Clan fame (with the aid of Eli Roth and Quentin Tarantino) makes a dual acting/directing appearance with this homage to Shaw Brothers martial arts films … not quite the genuine article but a solid effort where RZA certainly doesn’t embarrass himself

Paranormal Activity 4 (2012)

Paranormal Activity 4 (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Haunting Found Footage Film

The Paranormal Activity series has had a better run than most horror franchises up until now but the cracks are starting to show through here. This feels like it is straining to find some new way to do the familiar moves but fails to provide anything unexpected or original

Resident Evil: Retribution (2012)

Resident Evil: Retribution (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Videogame Adaptation/Complex of Zombies and Mutants

Another unnecessary entry in a creativity-handicapped series, the continuing popularity of which is baffles. This shuffles through the familiar moves, brings back several familiar characters but only leaves me asking why I have invested some nine hours of time following this series

The Scorpion King 3: Battle for Redemption (2012)

The Scorpion King 3: Battle for Redemption (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Sword and Sorcery

The best of an otherwise lightweight, throwaway series. Roel Reiné directs some good action scenes, even if the hackneyed plotting never lets the show rise to anything more than average

Evangelion 3.0: You Can (Not) Redo (2012)

Evangelion 3.0 You Can (Not) Redo (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Anime/Invasion by Vast Alien Machines

Third of the Neon Genesis Evangelion reboot films. These films are frustrating – filled with stunning scenes of mecha battling cryptic alien machines but baffling as to what is going on

The Dark Knight Rises (2012)

The Dark Knight Rises (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Comic-Book Superhero

The Dark Knight is a hard act to follow and Christopher Nolan almost does but not quite. The story keeps Batman off-screen for half the film. Tom Hardy’s Bane dominates the show, while Catwoman is surprisingly subdued

Men in Black 3 (2012)

Men in Black 3 (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Alien Coverup Conspiracy Agency

One hardly greets the attempt to generate another entry out of this franchise with any enthusiasm. This mostly consists of tired and familiar gags, where maybe the most generous compliment you can pay is that it is better than Men in Black II was

Outpost: Black Sun (2012)

Outpost: Black Sun (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Nazi Zombies

Outpost was a solid and reasonably effective rehashing of the Nazi zombie theme; this was the first of two sequels. The first had a formula that seems difficult to mess up but this does – it’s over half the film before we get zombies after which we get Just the Same As Before and little more

Death Race 3: Inferno (2012)

Death Race 3: Inferno (2012) poster
Rating: ★½
Future Prison/Gladiatorial Road Races

By tthis third film, the Death Race series is straining trying to find something original to do with a ry limited premise. The Death Race now takes place in the South African desert but the action scenes prove monotonous

Taichi Hero (2012)

Taichi Hero (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Wu Xia Film

Sequel to Stephen Fung’s Taichi Zero. The first film was distractingly self-conscious and hyper-active; by contrast, this is much less so, allowing it to settle down and start being the fantastic martial arts film it sets out to be. Even so, classic Wu Xia directors leave everything Fung does for dead

Taichi Zero (2012)

Taichi Zero (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Wu Xia Film

From the high-profile release this had, I was expecting it to be a Wu Xia epic – instead we get what feels like a martial arts film by way of Scott Pilgrim vs. the World where instead of amazing us with the fight scenes the director seems in love with self-conscious cuteness of his own visuals

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012)

The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Epic Fantasy Adventure

Peter Jackson returns to J.R.R. Tolkien and epic-sized adventure in the first of his Hobbit films. The visual sweep is there but the film feels over-extruded and over-burdened by its own self-importance.

The Pact (2012)

The Pact (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Haunting and Serial Killer

Modestly effective film about a haunted suburban house. Debuting director Nicholas McCarthy produces a number of accomplished and eerie scares that stand him as a promising new name. The film weakens in the last act when trying to tie everything together with an improbable rationale

Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance (2012)

Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance (2012) poster
Rating:
Comic-Book Avenger/Demonic Superhero

Ridiculous sequel to the Marvel Comics adaptation with an indifferently written script assembled from cliches, forgettable action scenes and Nicolas Cage giving one of his silliest performances in ages

Starship Troopers: Invasion (2012)

Starship Troopers: Invasion (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
War with Aliens/Anime

The importation of anime director Shinji Aramaki to helm the latest Starship Troopers film provides dazzling animation and hardware, along with some hard, furious military action that easily outstrips all the other films. On the other hand, the film never goes beyond being about soldiers shooting up bugs

Silent Hill: Revelation (2012)

Silent Hill: Revelation (2012) poster
Rating:
Videogame Adaptation/Sinister Otherworldly Town

Dull and unimaginative Silent Hill sequel that only revisits what went before. The first film had an uncanny otherworldly atmosphere but the sequel reduces everything to no more than pop-up Clive Barker

Hotel Transylvania (2012)

Hotel Transylvania (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Animation/Hotel for Famous Monsters

A variant on the much more charming Mad Monster Party?, an animated film featuring cute cuddly versions of the Famous Monsters (Dracula, Frankenstein’s monster, wolfman etc) with Adam Sandler voicing Dracula

Madagascar 3: Europe’s Most Wanted (2012)

Madagascar 3: Europe's Most Wanted (2012) poster
Rating: ★★½
Animation/Talking Animals

The Madagascar series was a cute idea first time around but has been stretched more than its worth by the sequels. Nevertheless, this works at you with a colourful light-heartedness that is hard to resist

Grave Encounters 2 (2012)

Grave Encounters 2 (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Found Footage/Meta-Fictional Sequel

Grave Encounters was an unremarkable Found Footage film. This much smarter sequel takes its lead from Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 in being a meta-fiction that investigates the phenomenon of the first film

Snow White and the Huntsman (2012)

Snow White and the Huntsman (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Adult Fairytale Adaptation/Epic Fantasy

The second of 2012’s Snow White films after Mirror Mirror, this turns the fairytale into an epic fantasy. Well produced but ultimately a film that lacks anything unique nor pushes far enough into the dark fantasy it promises to be

The Hunger Games (2012)

The Hunger Games (2012) poster 2
Rating: ★★½
Future Televised Human Hunting

A Young Adult box-office hit that does little more than competently shuffle around ideas from other SF films. Jennifer Lawrence makes an impressive showing but the film also soft-pedals the moral reality of its scenario

The ABCs of Death (2012)

The ABCs of Death (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Horror Anthology

Unique anthology that offers 26 episodes from different directors, each ending with a death. The episodes vary wildly in quality but a sufficient number ignore all good taste and/or travel waaaay across taboo lines

[Rec]3: Genesis (2012)

[Rec]3 Genesis (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Zombie Outbreak at a Wedding

Third entry in the Spanish Found Footage series. The Found Footage look is abandoned soon in but this decides to have fun and turns out the gore-drenched goods

V/H/S (2012)

V/H/S (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Anthology of Found Footage Horror Tales

An anthology of five short Found Footage horror films each from a different director. As with any anthology these are variable in tone but are on the whole mostly effective and contain a number of alternately unearthly and spooky moments

2-Headed Shark Attack (2012)

2-Headed Shark Attack (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Giant Shark Amok

This is a killer shark film that is not taking itself too seriously. In their pursuit for the most absurd monster movie title, The Asylum have managed to get the balance of cheap effects and tongue-in-cheek treatment down near perfectly. The first in a series from The Asylum where each sequel added more heads.

Underworld: Awakening (2012)

Underworld: Awakening (2012) poster
Rating: ★½
Vampire-Werewolf War

Yet another entry that nobody asked for in a conceptually threadbare series that nobody seems to like … passably better than the last two sequels due to some ok action moves but still empty-headed in terms of ideas

Universal Soldier: Day of Reckoning (2012)

Universal Soldier: Day of Reckoning (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Super-Soldiers/Action/Identity Bender

Sixth entry in the series, this throws out all the themes the previous sequels operated by and feels like a Universal Soldier film written by Philip K. Dick with utterly fascinating results. John Hyams hits in with a brutal intensity that shows he is one of the most exciting up and coming action directors

Kirikou and the Men and Women (2012)

Kirikou and the Men and Women (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Animation/African Folk Tales

The third of Michel Ocelot’s Kirikou films, delightful tales about the ingenuity and plain-speaking wisdom of a young boy winning out over adult pomposity and foolishness. Animated with a simplicity that is magical

Journey 2: The Mysterious Island (2012)

Journey 2: The Mysterious Island (2012) poster
Rating:
Jules Verne Adaptation/Island of Giant Fauna

Sequel to Journey to the Center of the Earth, a supposed adaptation of Jules Verne’s Mysterious Island and a consistently silly, nonsensical film that operates at the level of a children’s cartoon

The Avengers (2012)

The Avengers (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Marvel Comics Superhero Team-Up

The culmination of one of the most ambitious cinematic exercises ever conducted, with Marvel weaving storylines through several films to finally merge here with flawless regard. The characters get far more depth than in all of their previous films

Atlas Shrugged II: The Strike (2012)

Atlas Shrugged II: The Strike (2012) poster
Rating:
Libertarian Political Fantasy/Ayn Rand Adaptation

The second film from Ayn Rand’s libertarian fantasy. This gets more into the meat of Rand’s ideas (wherein the wealthy decide to ignore an undeserving world) and is even more ridiculous than the first film

Asterix and Obelix: God Save Britannia (2012)

Asterix and Obelix: God Save Britannia (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Comic-Book Character

Fourth of the live-action films adapted from the Asterix comic-books with Gerard Depardieu as Obelix. This replicates the absurdist historical wit of the originals while poking fun at the foibles of the British

The Amazing Spider-Man (2012)

The Amazing Spider-Man (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Comic-Book Superhero

The reasoning behind rebooting the Spider-Man franchise after ten years and only three films is a puzzle. That said, this offers an edgier origin story than Sam Raimi’s take and Andrew Garfield makes for a fine Spider-Man

Breaking Dawn Part Two (2012)

Breaking Dawn Part Two (2012) poster
Rating: ★★
Twilight Sequel/Vampire Romance

Perhaps the best thing about this is that the Twilight saga is finally ended. This provides a moderately spectacular showdown but also wraps its plotlines up with absurd deus ex machina wimp outs and an infuriating twist ending

Battlestar Galactica: Blood & Chrome (2012)

Battlestar Galactica: Blood & Chrome (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Space Opera/Web Series Prequel

Web-series/film prequel to the 2003-9 revival of Battlestar Galactica with a rookie Commander Adama arriving aboard the Galactica. Easily one the best of the Galactica spinoff films to date

The Thompsons (2012)

The Thompsons (2012) poster
Rating: ★½
Family of Vampires

The Hamiltons was an unusual film about a strange family who were eventually revealed to be vampires. By the time of this sequel, all the interesting elements of the original have been eliminated and all that we have is a film of tired poses that fails to add anything to the overworked vampire genre

Iron Sky (2012)

Iron Sky (2012) poster
Rating: ★★★
Nazi Flying Saucers from the Moon

Finnish filmmaker Timo Vuorensola makes a conceptually wild film about invasion by Nazi flying saucers from the Moon. Stunning quality effects on a minuscule budget that rival the work of professional houses

G.I. Joe: Retaliation (2013)

G.I. Joe: Retaliation (2013) poster
Rating: ★★
Futuristic Military Action Team

You can’t complain that this is not exactly what you expect it to be – two hours of cartoonish action during which the brain singularly fails to engage. This is less unapologetic about being a military fantasy than the first film

V/H/S/2 (2013)

V/H/S/2 (2013) poster
Rating: ★★
Anthology of Found Footage Horror Tales

Sequel to the modest success of V/H/S, an anthology of short Found Footage horror films featuring a different line-up of genre directors. The episodes are competent at best, none standout and mostly forgettable

R.I.P.D. (2013)

R.I.P.D. (2013) poster
Rating: ★★
Afterlife Police Force

This feels like someone has simply copied the idea of a secretive law enforcement agency from and substituted the dead escaped from Hell for aliens. The two have remarkably similar story arcs, although this is far more goofily entertaining that the absurdly overblown slapstick that overtook the Men in Black sequels

Contracted (2013)

Contracted (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★
Deadly Infection/Heroine's Physical Decay

Modestly effective effort about a woman who contracts an infection that causes her to physically decay. The horror comes in watching the heroine’s progressive physical decomposition.

Texas Chainsaw (2013)

Texas Chainsaw (2013) poster
Rating:
Backwoods Brutality

A Texas Chainsaw sequel in 3D with chainsaws and gore coming out at the screen seems the complete antithesis of the raw savagery of the original. The result is like a formulaic modern slasher, while the film is wrecked by a ridiculous reversal of sympathies in the last half

Insidious Chapter 2 (2013)

Insidious Chapter 2 (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★
Haunting/Possession

James Wan proves himself one of the finest directors in the horror genre with this sequel to his 2010 film. The plot is trimmed to deliver an effective scare show and Wan again produces a series of eerie and unworldly jumps

Thor: The Dark World (2013)

Thor: The Dark World (2013) poster
Rating: ★★½
Marvel Comics Norse God Superhero

Sequel to Thor that earranges the same basic elements much more satisfyingly than the first film – the actors (with the exception of a tranquilised Natalie Portman) seem more at home in their roles and a director who is more confident with the effects and superheroics. That said, it is starting to feel like Marvel is shuffling the same plot ingredients around between films

Fright Night 2 (2013)

Fright Night 2 (2013) poster
Rating: ½
Vampire Film

Supposedly a sequel to the 2011 Fright Night remake but more a loose reworking of the original. This conducts some novel variations such as making Jerry Dandridge into a woman, but is also one of the worst directed horror films in some time

Oz: The Great and Powerful (2013)

Oz: The Great and Powerful (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★
The Wizard of Oz Prequel

Sam Raimi’s prequel to The Wizard of Oz is now; the story of how a conman fools an entire land rather than of an innocent girl just trying to find her way home. The reconceptualisation of Oz comes with a colourful sweep

The Purge (2013)

The Purge (2013) poster
Rating: ★★
Future That Permits One Night of Lawlessness

Film based around the improbable concept of a future where on one night of each year all crime including murder becomes permissible. While this promises a rich vein of satire, the film only emerges as a variant on Straw Dogs

Hansel & Gretel (2013)

Hansel and Gretel (2014) poster
Rating: ★★★
Fairytale Horror Adaptation

Amid the 2010s spate of fairytales rewritten as dark adult fantasies, this was a quite good mockbuster copy from The Asylum. From the director of Sharknado, this is Hansel and Gretel by way of The Texas Chain Saw Massacre

Sharknado (2013)

Sharknado (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★
Storm of Sharks/Deliberately Bad Film

This arrived as the same instant full-born bad movie cult sensation. Although you cannot help but feel that the people who ridiculed the film are missing out on the joke – in not seeing that it has been made as something intentionally absurd

Pacific Rim (2013)

Pacific Rim (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Giant Mecha Robots vs Giant Monsters

Giant mecha robots beating the crap out of giant monsters – what’s not to like? In comparison to the Transformers films, Guillermo Del Toro looks to find the soul of the robot jock – in essence, Transformers for grown-ups

Wolf Creek 2 (2013)

Wolf Creek 2 (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Australian Backwoods Brutality

Greg McLean and John Jarratt return to the Australian Backwood Brutality saga of Wolf Creek for a second outing that is just as effective as the first. McLean often pushes the material into black humour and creates at least one sequence that makes for genuinely uncomfortable watching

Monsters University (2013)

Monsters University (2013) poster
Rating: ★★
Pixar Animation/Monsters in the Closet

Pixar’s creative decline has been the point they started making these sequels to their hits. This is a disappointing prequel to Monsters, Inc. that largely recycles the cliches of the Revenge of the Nerds films and seems lacking in any of the wacky humour or moments of cuteness we expect of a Pixar film

The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013)

The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (2013) poster
Rating: ★½
Epic Fantasy Adventure

The Hobbit became Peter Jackson’s equivalent of the Star Wars prequels and this is the weakest work he has produced under the J.R.R. Tolkien banner. Five picaresque chapters of the book are extruded into bloated set-pieces