You’ll Never Find Me (2023)

You'll Never Find Me (2023) poster
Rating: ★★½
Psychological Games Between Two Strangers

Australian film where a girl turns up at the trailer home of a recluse. A series of tense psychological games ensue where it becomes apparent neither of them are being truthful

The Wailing (2016)

The Wailing (2016) poster
Rating: ★★½
Korean Horror/Possession/Mysterious Stranger

South Korean horror film that generates a more than effectively creepy atmosphere. The downside is that you reached the end of the show with no clear idea what is going on and why things are happening

Visitor Q (2001)

Visitor Q (2001) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Catalogue of Perversions/Mysterious Visitor/Black Comedy

One of the key films in the cult of Takashi Miike that has been frequently banned for its taboo-defying outrages in which a mysterious visitor causes a family household to descend into perverse extremes

The Visitation (2006)

The Visitation (2006) poster
Rating: ★★½
Christian Film/Ambiguous Miracle-Healing Stranger

The novelty of the first Christian horror film. As opposed to much of the message-heavy tripe that usually gets peddled in this niche market, this is actually well structured with a number of interesting ambiguities and engaging as a story for the better part

The Traveler (2010)

The Traveler (2010) poster
Rating: ★★
Mysterious Stranger

This has the intriguing hook of casting 1990s teen heartthrob Val Kilmer as a supernaturally empowered mysterious stranger. It soon becomes apparent that the film is a variant on Clint Eastwood’s High Plains Drifter. After blowing its twist soon in, the film only proceeds to a desultory ending

Three Wishes (1995)

Rating: ★★½
1950s Coming of Age Tale/Mysterious Stranger

This is a 1950s Coming of Age story with Patrick Swayze as a mysterious stranger dispensing wisdom, before the film arrives at a very peculiar fantastic ending

These Streets We Haunt (2021)

These Streets We Haunt (2021) poster
Rating: ★★★
Man’s Roommate May be a Super-Villain

An eccentrically oddball comedy in which a man discovers that his strange roommate may be a comic-book super-villain. Made independently but with a dry wit that is hard to resist

Strange Cargo (1940)

Strange Cargo (1940) poster
Rating: ★★★
Jesus Christ Aids Devil's Island Escapees

One of the strangest films of the 1940s, featuring Clark Gable, Joan Crawford and others as a group of Devil’s Island escapees who realise during the course of their journey that one of the company is Jesus Christ

Storm of the Century (1999)

Storm of the Century (1999) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Stranger Manipulates a Small Town/Stephen King Mini-Series

One of the best Stephen King tv mini-series with Colm Feore as a mysterious stranger who manipulates and turns an entire town against themselves

The Shout (1978)

The Shout (1978) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Enigmatic Stranger With Supernatural Powers

A film of fascinating ambiguities that stars Alan Bates as a mystery man who appears to John Hurt and demonstrates a killing shout he learned among the Aborigines

Secret Window (2004)

Secret Window (2004) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Sinister Stranger/Stephen King Adaptation

Stephen King adaptation with Johnny Depp as a writer in a cabin in the woods harassed by mysterious stranger John Turturro. Screenwriter David Koepp directs a marvellously chill Turturro with lots of twisty surprises

Outside Satan (2011)

Outside Satan (2011) poster
Rating: ★★★
Ambiguous Miraculous Visitor

In the vein of Pasolini’s Teorema, French director Bruno Dumont makes a film about an ambiguous visitor who may be capable of miracles. Slow, very opaque but eventually rewarding

Mary Poppins Returns (2018)

Mary Poppins Returns (2018) poster
Rating: ★★
Flying Nanny Frolics

Mary Poppins was one of the greatest of all Disney live-action films, made with nonsensical charm and has become a much loved favourite. As part of the ongoing firesale that involves resurrecting almost all of their properties, this is a sequel. Its an exacting replication/homage to the original but that is the problem – it is a recapturing rather than seems to create its own sparkle

Man Facing Southeast (1986)

Man Facing Southeast (1986) poster
Rating: ★★★★★
Christ-like Alien Visitor in a Psychiatric Institution

An extraordinary Argentinean film about a patient in his asylum who insists that he is an alien and has genteel affect on the inmates. Later uncreditedly ripped-off as K-PAX.

Let Us Prey (2014)

Let Us Prey (2014) poster
Rating: ★★★
Mysterious Stranger/Supernatural Retribution

A rather effective effort about a Mysterious Stranger locked in a cell who proceeds to expose the dark secrets of everybody around him, before a completely whacked ending

Hold Your Breath (2024)

Hold Your Breath (2024) poster
Rating: ★★★
Possibly Imagined Horrors in the Dust Bowl

This has quite a few similarities to the underrated The Wind with Sarah Paulson as a mother in the 1930s Dustbowl seeing possible supernatural figures amid the dust storms, which could just as easily be fraying sanity

High Plains Drifter (1973)

High Plains Drifter (1973) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Western/Supernatural Retribution

A Clint Eastwood directed/starring Western in which he plays a gunslinger who turns up in a town and exposes the guilty secrets of the townspeople in what is eventually revealed to be a supernatural twist

The Guest (2014)

The Guest (2014) poster
Rating: ★★★
Sinister Stranger

Adam Wingard thriller about a sinister stranger who inveigles his way into a household. This does well playing off the handsomely polished charms of Dan Stevens, less well when it turns into an a left field action film

Funny Games U.S. (2007)

Funny Games U.S. (2007) poster
Rating: ★★★
Sadism and Torture

Michael Haneke’s English-language remake of his earlier home invasion film has a sense of pointlessness to it. But in following the original so closely, it also cannot help but work where it did

Funny Games (1997)

Funny Games (1997) poster
Rating: ★★★★
Sadism and Torture

Brutal Michael Haneke film where a family’s weekend getaway becomes a nightmare when two boys enter the house and proceed to torture and kill them. Haneke adds a level of meta-fiction that taunts the viewer’s participation

The Final Storm (2010)

The Final Storm (2010) poster
Rating: ★★
Mysterious Stranger/Possible Biblical End of the World

Uwe Boll seems to be improving. Here he has abandoned action for a character-driven drama about the appearance of an ambiguous stranger heralding the Biblical end of the world

The End of the Animal (2010)

The End of the Animal (2010) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Mysterious Catastrophe/Godlike Stranger

Fascinating no-budget South Korean film about a mysterious catastrophe and an even more mysterious godlike stranger who appears in its aftermath. Enigma like the best of Andrei Tarkovsky

Death Takes a Holiday (1934)

Death Takes a Holiday (1934) poster
Rating: ★★★
Death Takes on Human Form

Classic fantasy film in which Death takes human form to visit a party and experience the human condition. Frederic March gives us Death as a comically eccentric outsider and the film has some great moments of imagination

Darkside Blues (1994)

Darkside Blues (1994) poster
Rating: ★★
Anime/Dark Future/Mysterious Stranger

Anime where a mysterious other-dimensional stranger aids future rebels. This has a wonderfully ornate Gothic feel but an entirely confusing plot

Dante 01 (2008)

Dante 01 (2008) poster
Rating: ★★
Insane Asylum on a Space Station

Finally, the answer to what happened to Marc Caro after parting ways with Jean-Pierre Jeunet. Caro directs what would appear to be a darkly lit and confusing variation on The Green Mile set on a space station

The Caller (1987)

The Caller (1987) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Strange Psychological Games/Reality Bender

Unexpectedly good film with Madolyn Smith as a woman living alone in a cabin in the woods and Malcolm McDowell as a caller where the two engage in a series of cat and mouse games where nothing is what it seems

The Box (2009)

The Box (2009) poster
Rating:
Mysterious Stranger Offers Couple a Terrible Choice

Donnie Darko director Richard Kelly adapts a Richard Matheson story about a couple who are offered a terrible choice by a stranger but delivers a bafflingly incomprehensible film

Borgman (2013)

Borgman (2013) poster
Rating: ★★★½
Mysterious Stranger Invades a Household

A cryptically surreal Dutch film that comes with hilariously black deadpan effect as we watch a homeless man inveigle his way into a household and take over before starting to eliminate people.

Blood River (2009)

Blood River (2009) poster
Rating: ★★½
Sinister Hitchhiker/Divine Judgement

An interesting little film from Adam Mason that starts out seeming a variant on The Hitcher with Andrew Howard as a drifter taunting a couple on a desert highway before morphing into something very strange

Black Butterfly (2017)

Black Butterfly (2007) poster
Rating: ★★
Sinister Stranger Invades a Writer’s Home

Antonio Banderas is a writer with a block, Jonathan Rhys Meyers a sinister stranger who moves in. Lots of tense psychological games between the two begin only for the film to almost immediately blow the premise